Prime Minister and PKR president Anwar Ibrahim at the Jelajah Harapan Melaka Rumah Kita grand finale in Bukit Baru, Melaka, on 12 November 2026. Photo: BERNAMA
After Barisan Nasional and Perikatan Nasional won 24 of Melaka’s 28 seats on 14 November, BN chairman Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi called the result a “hat-trick of wins”, following wins in Johor in July and Negeri Sembilan in August. He said the outcome continued a “blue wave momentum“. For Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim’s Pakatan Harapan, the question is whether these contests, and last year’s Sabah poll, show a loss of Malay support.
The seat tallies are not in dispute, but what they mean for Malay voting is more complicated. Analysts say PH is weak among Malay voters, and that BN–PN co-operation has made that more costly in seats. They also caution against reading a sudden collapse into every state, or treating Sabah as a test of peninsula Malay sentiment.
Johor: a large swing, mainly from PN to BN
BN won 48 of Johor’s 56 seats on 11 July, up from 40 in 2022, with about 59.7 per cent of the popular vote. PH fell from 12 seats to eight. Its vote share was 32.6 per cent, down from 42.6 per cent at the 2022 general election but up from 26.4 per cent in the 2022 state poll. PN won no seats. ElectionData.MY put official turnout at 69.57 per cent, up from 54.92 per cent in 2022. BN contested all 56 seats alone, after PH had expected a joint campaign with its federal partner.
Former Bangi MP Dr Ong Kian Ming first offered an “educated guess” that about 85 per cent of Malays who turned out backed BN. In a later estimate, he put BN’s share of Malay ballots at about 84.9 per cent, and said BN’s support among the eligible Malay electorate rose from an estimated 36.5 per cent in 2022 to 64.1 per cent, while PN fell from 34.5 per cent to 6.8 per cent, “almost exactly one-for-one”.
Bridget Welsh, analysing polling-station data, estimated PH’s Malay support in Johor at about 7 per cent, and said “it was also this low in 2022”. The Ilham Centre recorded Menteri Besar Datuk Onn Hafiz Ghazi’s popularity among respondents at 79 per cent, against 40 per cent for Anwar, and found voters judged the state government ahead of the federal one.
Negeri Sembilan: a pact, and two estimates
On 1 August, the BN–PN electoral pact won 25 of 36 seats. PH lost the state, falling from 17 seats to 11. Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Aminuddin Harun and DAP secretary-general Anthony Loke both lost. Turnout was 72.6 per cent. PH still led the popular vote, at about 40.2 per cent in a paper by Tricia Yeoh for the ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute, or 39.7 per cent in Ong’s tally.
Estimates of PH’s Malay support do not agree. The Ilham Centre, in a pre-election survey, put it at 18 per cent. Ong’s initial post-election estimate was “less than 10 per cent, at around 8 per cent”, with about 80 per cent of Malay voters backing BN or PN. Welsh also estimated that about 80 per cent of Malays supported the BN–PN arrangement, but put PH’s Malay share at about 18 per cent, close to her figure of 19 per cent in 2022. She argued PH “was not ‘wiped’ out among Malays as it was in Johor”.
Yeoh said PH’s Malay support had “declined drastically since 2018”, from an average of 31 per cent at the 2018 general election, when Bersatu was still in PH, to 19 per cent in 2022, then 43 per cent in 2023, when PH campaigned alongside BN, and 8–10 per cent in 2026. Merdeka Center estimated that PH would have needed about 36–38 per cent of the Malay vote to win 19 seats. The 2023 figure is not like-for-like, because PH candidates then also collected BN’s Malay votes.
Melaka: fewer seats, no ethnic breakdown yet
In Melaka, BN won 21 seats and PN three, with turnout of 71.77 per cent. PH won four, down from five in 2021, all urban Chinese-majority seats. The Star reported that BN took 240,651 votes, or 49.2 per cent, up from 38.39 per cent in 2021, when BN and PN contested separately. PH’s share fell from 35.80 per cent to 29.3 per cent.
No post-election estimate of the Malay vote has been published. A pre-poll Ilham Centre study of 805 respondents found 91 per cent of PN voters willing to switch to BN and 78 per cent of BN voters to PN, and said PH had “failed to make significant gains among Malay voters, fence-sitters and rural communities”. Melaka PH chairman Adly Zahari had earlier said the coalition needed “more than 30 per cent of the Malay vote” to win most of the seats it contested. After losing his Bukit Katil seat, he said PH accepted the outcome “as part of the democratic process”.
Sabah: a different election
Sabah’s election on 29 November 2025 is often added to the same list, but is a weak measure of peninsula Malay support. PH won only one of the 22 seats it contested, with about 7.1 per cent of the vote. In 2020 it had won eight seats as part of the Warisan+ alliance, so the comparison is not clean. Welsh estimated that PH support among Malay, Bugis and Sungai voters fell from about 6 per cent at the 2022 general election to about 3 per cent, and that Bajau support was about 1 per cent in both contests. Accounts described a swing towards local parties, not a peninsula-style Malay realignment.
What the results do not settle
PH’s Malay support in Johor was already estimated to be very low in the 2022 state election. In Negeri Sembilan, Welsh’s figure is close to her 2022 estimate. Seat losses often reflect alliance changes: BN contested Johor alone, and in Negeri Sembilan and Melaka it stood with PN instead of PH. State elections can also understate PH when its non-Malay base stays home. Ong estimated that about two-thirds of PH’s decline among Johor’s eligible Chinese electorate, versus 2022, came from lower turnout, not a switch to BN.
Local incumbency matters too. Ilham found Onn Hafiz and Datuk Seri Ab Rauf Yusoh far more popular in their states than a national reading of Anwar would imply, and put Ab Rauf’s Melaka approval at 86 per cent and the state government’s at 85 per cent. The published estimates are stronger on PH’s continuing weakness among Malay voters, and on the effect of BN–PN co-operation, than on a fresh collapse across all four states. A post-election estimate of Melaka’s Malay vote is not yet available.

