Photo: Wee Hong / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
KUALA LUMPUR, November 17, 2026 — Pakatan Harapan Member of Parliament for Kampar Chong Zhemin has filed a substantive motion asking the Dewan Rakyat to review Deputy Speaker Datuk Seri Ramli Mohd Nor’s decision to take part in a Budget 2027 debate while still presiding over the sitting.
Chong said he submitted the notice under Standing Order 43 today, and that the Speaker’s Office had received it, the New Straits Times reported. The Star said the motion was submitted to Dewan Rakyat Speaker Tan Sri Johari Abdul.
The motion concerns Monday’s committee-stage debate on the Works Ministry’s allocation. Ramli, who is also the Member of Parliament for Cameron Highlands, announced that he would join the debate, left the Speaker’s chair and spoke from the Members’ bench while saying he was still presiding, The Star and the New Straits Times reported.
Datuk Seri Ronald Kiandee, the Perikatan Nasional Member of Parliament for Beluran, objected and asked who was overseeing the sitting, suggesting that another Member of Parliament should temporarily take the chair. Ramli said he had checked the Standing Orders and found no prohibition. “YB, I am chairing and have chosen to speak from my seat (on the MPs’ bench). I have checked and this does not go against any rules,” The Star quoted him as saying on Monday.
Deputy Speaker Alice Lau subsequently took over the chair while Ramli delivered his speech, The Star reported. Datuk Ngeh Koo Ham, the Pakatan Harapan Member of Parliament for Beruas, said leaving the Speaker’s chair empty was disrespectful to the House and warned that Parliament risked becoming a laughing stock. He called for the episode to be expunged from the Hansard. Datuk Seri Dr Zaliha Mustafa, the Member of Parliament for Sekijang and chairman of the Government Backbenchers Club, also sought clear guidance. Ramli invoked Standing Order 99 and said Members who disagreed could file a motion.
Chong’s motion, as reported by The Star, asks the House to review Ramli’s decision of 16 November 2026. Under Standing Order 43, a ruling by the Speaker or Chairman on a point of order is final and not subject to appeal except through a substantive motion. Chong argued that allowing a presiding officer to debate while remaining in the chair was inconsistent with Standing Order 35(1), which requires a member wishing to speak to be called upon by the Chair and to address their speech to the Chair.
“So I want to ask: who gave the member for Cameron Highlands his turn to speak when he began to debate? And if there is an objection to his speech, who will decide the objection?” he told a press conference in Parliament today, the New Straits Times reported. “If he acts as both member of parliament and chair at the same time, how can he address his speech to himself?”
While agreeing with Ramli that the Standing Orders were silent on the matter, Chong said he had checked Commonwealth parliamentary conventions and found the situation unprecedented. The motion, he said, sought a review of Monday’s decision and a ruling that any deputy speaker who wished to debate as a Member of Parliament must first relinquish the chair and speak only after being called upon.
Ngeh, who also spoke at the press conference, said a Speaker or chairman must preside during the committee stage, and that when Members questioned the conduct, Ramli repeatedly instructed them to sit down and invoked Standing Order 99.
No public response from Ramli or the Speaker to today’s motion had been reported at the time of writing.
Sources: The Star; The Star (Monday sitting); New Straits Times.

