PAS and Barisan Nasional flags during the 2013 general election campaign (file photo). Photo: Firdaus Latif / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0 (cropped). The image is illustrative.
Analysis
PETALING JAYA, 19 Nov — A revived Barisan Alternatif (BA) that brings PAS together with PKR but leaves out DAP could split the Malay vote while costing PKR non-Malay support, a political analyst has told Free Malaysia Today. A second analyst argued that PAS would still have reasons to consider such a partnership.
The idea was raised in the latest episode of the Keluar Sekejap podcast, where former Umno Youth chief Khairy Jamaluddin said reviving BA could “save” Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim from the threat posed by the Barisan Nasional–Perikatan Nasional (BN-PN) alliance, FMT reported. Khairy said Pakatan Harapan (PH) needed a Malay bloc, while co-host Shahril Hamdan said the only way to win PAS over would be to drop DAP. Khairy acknowledged a revival would be difficult.
BA was formed in 1999 during the Reformasi movement that followed Anwar’s dismissal as deputy prime minister, bringing together Parti Keadilan Nasional (now PKR), DAP, PAS and Parti Rakyat Malaysia.
‘Malay votes will be split’
Syaza Shukri of the International Islamic University Malaysia said such a scenario would give PAS no strong reason to abandon Umno, which it is courting for a pact at the 16th general election.
She said a partnership with Umno could help PAS secure up to 80 per cent of the Malay vote, pointing to the BN-PN alliance’s wins in the Negeri Sembilan and Melaka elections. Joining PKR under BA, she said, would put PAS back in competition with Umno and BN for Malay voters.
“So the Malay votes will be split, while the non-Malay votes will go to DAP,” she told FMT.
Syaza said one possible common ground would be the anti-corruption agenda that BA championed in 1999. “Right now, both PAS and Anwar are linked to BN, which has corruption scandals of its own. It’s possible they would both distance themselves from BN (because of the scandals) and work together,” she said.
Seats and oil royalty
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia’s Mazlan Ali offered a different view, saying PAS could gain the lion’s share of Malay-majority seats and more Cabinet posts by working with PH. He said an Umno-PAS pact would struggle over seat distribution because both parties target similar constituencies.
“However, if PAS works with Anwar, PAS would definitely be allocated more Malay-majority areas because Anwar and PH would be willing to make way for PAS there,” he said, citing PH’s strength among urban and progressive voters.
Mazlan said resolving the oil royalty demands of Kelantan and Terengganu could be another incentive. “Offering oil royalties would definitely attract PAS,” he said.
Party positions
Both PKR and PAS leaders have publicly dismissed the idea. PKR vice-president Dr Zaliha Mustafa told FMT on 18 November that PKR would not sideline DAP to win Malay support, describing DAP as a loyal partner since the BA era. PAS deputy president Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man called Khairy’s suggestion a personal view, saying any decision on cooperation must go to the party’s Majlis Syura Ulama and that PAS considered the BN-PN partnership sufficient for the next general election, FMT reported.
Separately, Amanah communications director Khalid Samad urged PAS earlier this week to consider ending its cooperation with Umno and backing Anwar’s government, saying Amanah could help lead discussions if PAS wished to join the administration, according to FMT.
Sources: Free Malaysia Today, Free Malaysia Today, Free Malaysia Today (BM).
Featured image: PAS and Barisan Nasional flags during the 2013 general election campaign (file photo, illustrative). Photo: Firdaus Latif / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

